Market volatility presents opportunities to examine how emotions influence financial choices. When markets decline, natural instincts might suggest getting more conservative in the hope of reducing risk “until things settle down.” On the other hand, during periods of sustained growth, excitement might tempt us toward increased risk with the goal of capturing a higher level of growth. These emotional responses often stem from deeply rooted behavioral patterns that affect financial decision making.
Financial decisions tend to follow recognizable patterns that may influence investment choices:
Loss Response: Many investors feel market declines more intensely than equivalent gains. For example, losing $100 creates twice the emotional response as gaining $100. This natural response might lead to selling investments during market downturns, potentially missing the subsequent recovery.
Present Focus: Recent market events often carry more weight in decision-making than long-term historical patterns. However, once we are a year or two removed from current events, we often have trouble recalling the level of volatility previously experienced. Consider 2022, when the market contracted 25% at its lowest point (Source: Yahoo Finance)—yet in conversations today, I've found that most people have only a vague memory of this downturn. This tendency may cause investors to overemphasize current market conditions when making financial choices.
Group Influence: Making investment decisions based on popular trends might feel reassuring, but following the crowd does not always align with individual financial objectives and risk considerations.
Performance Gap: Research by DALBAR consistently shows that average equity fund investors significantly underperform market indices over 10, 20, and 30-year horizons. This gap isn't primarily due to market conditions but rather behavioral and practical factors. For instance, emotional decision-making often leads to a "buy high, sell low" pattern that's the largest single contributor to long-term underperformance.
Following recognizable patterns in market psychology, several specific behaviors consistently erode investor returns:
Market-Timing Fallacy: Attempts to time the market often result in missing the few critical days that drive most of a year's gains. Even modest market drawdowns can prompt withdrawals, causing investors to miss the rapid rebounds that typically follow significant sell-offs.
Herd Mentality: Money tends to flow into last year's winners (often at peak valuations) and out of last year's underperformers, perpetuating the cycle of buying high and selling low. Following the crowd rather than adhering to a disciplined plan can amplify market swings.
Short-Termism & Excessive Trading: Frequent buying and selling not only incurs transaction costs but can trigger taxable events, both of which erode returns. Recency bias—overweighting recent performance when making allocation decisions—often leads to ill-timed portfolio shifts.
Hidden Costs: Beyond emotional decisions, expense ratios, trading costs, and tax inefficiencies can significantly impact long-term performance. Even small timing errors compound over decades, potentially reducing annual returns by 0.8–3.2 percentage points according to long-term studies.
Understanding these behavioral patterns allows for more thoughtful financial decision making. Consider these strategies:
Establish Clear Parameters: Define investment guidelines, risk tolerance, and rebalancing thresholds before market turbulence occurs. This framework helps maintain perspective during volatile periods.
Focus on Long-term Objectives: Short-term market movements matter less than progress toward established financial goals. Regular review of these objectives helps maintain appropriate context especially when measuring progress during a contraction.
Document Your Strategy: Writing down investment rationale and revisiting it during market stress supports more disciplined decision-making.
Implement Automated Processes: Consider dollar-cost averaging and disciplined rebalancing to reduce the impact of emotional decision-making.
Create Decision Rules: Establish pre-committed rules for withdrawals and contributions that aren't influenced by current market conditions.
Understand Market Patterns: Historical data shows that markets have been in correction territory approximately 30% of the time since 1980. However, a balanced portfolio has averaged approximately 8+% per year capturing almost 90% of market growth while reducing risk by almost 30%. Recognizing that volatility is a normal part of investing helps maintain perspective during downturns.
Conduct Regular "Bias Check-ins": Periodically review investment decisions to identify patterns of emotional bias and correct course as needed.
A wealth advisor serves as an objective partner, helping identify and navigate these behavioral patterns and focus on pragmatic decisions as opposed to emotional decisions. Professional guidance may provide:
The difference between market returns and actual investor returns is largely attributable to behavioral factors rather than market conditions. By understanding these patterns and implementing structured approaches to investment decisions, investors can potentially capture more of the market's long-term growth potential. Professional guidance focused on behavioral discipline—including automated investments, strict rebalancing, and pre-committed decision rules—can significantly improve real investor outcomes over time.
–
Every investor brings unique circumstances and risk tolerances that should shape their investment strategy and ultimately determine how they pursue their financial goals. We welcome the opportunity to discuss how these concepts might apply to your specific situation and explore how professional guidance could support your long-term financial goals.
This content is provided for educational purposes only, represents only a summary of topics discussed, does not constitute any personalized investment advice or recommendation, and represents only the views and opinions of the speakers which are subject to change without notice. Investing involves risk including the potential loss of all amounts invested.
This material prepared by Certus Wealth Management, LLC (“Certus Wealth”) is for informational purposes only. It is not intended to serve as a substitute for personalized investment advice or as a recommendation or solicitation of any particular security, strategy or investment product. Opinions expressed by Certus Wealth are based on economic or market conditions at the time this material was written. Economies and markets fluctuate. Actual economic or market events may turn out differently than anticipated. Facts presented have been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. Certus Wealth, however, cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information, and certain information presented here may have been condensed or summarized from its original source. Certus Wealth does not provide tax or legal advice, and nothing contained in these materials should be taken as tax or legal advice.